[Report] The Code IS the Law: Norm-Shaping by Private Companies in Cybersecurity Governance in Outer Space - CODE BLUE 2026 #codeblue_jp #codeblue2026

[Report] The Code IS the Law: Norm-Shaping by Private Companies in Cybersecurity Governance in Outer Space - CODE BLUE 2026 #codeblue_jp #codeblue2026

A report on the CODE BLUE 2026 session "The Code IS the Law: Norm Formation by Private Companies in Space Cybersecurity Governance."
2026.11.18

This page has been translated by machine translation. View original

Hello, this is Usuda.

Everyone, are you taking security measures? (greeting)

This time, it's a report on the following session held at CODE BLUE 2026.

The Code IS the Law: Norm-Making by Private Companies in Cybersecurity Governance of Outer Space

Who governs (manages) cybersecurity in orbit? Not states. As satellite broadband providers such as Starlink become critical infrastructure in times of crisis, it is not international treaties but the engineering choices and contractual practices of private companies that are filling this "normative vacuum."

Based on research on satellite broadband governance and the role technology plays in the development of international norms, this talk reveals how satellite operators function as "de facto lawmakers" through three mechanisms. These three are the development of technical standards, chains of contracts spanning legal jurisdictions (contract cascades), and crisis response actions during emergencies (such as the 2022 cyberattack on Viasat, in which norms emerged in the midst of the attack).

As a result, an accountability gap has arisen. Rules exist, but no state has agreed to them, and no court can review them. This talk proposes reintegrating this norm-making by private companies into the international legal order through due diligence and mandates. It then asks what existing state-oriented guidance (such as the "Handbook on National Positions" issued in 2025 by the CCDCOE (NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence) and the Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs) overlooks in a situation where private actors rewrite the rules first.

Speakers: Joanna Kulesza Joanna Kulesza

Report

  • I won't talk about AI today
  • It's a talk about space security
  • The infrastructure there and what is happening
  • Self-introduction
    • An expert in international law
    • Also runs the Cyber Hub at the University of Lodz
    • Provides answers to engineers from international law
    • The basis is existing international law
    • Explains how technology and international law relate to urgent issues
    • Security of satellite orbits
  • Lodz Cyber Hub
    • Holds a conference in Brussels around February at the European Security College
    • Participants from outside the EU as well
    • Non-profit activity
  • Problem statement
    • Three elements
    • Space is not governed, and is also called a new frontier
    • Some people think it is free to bring resources from the Moon
    • Without an international legal framework
  • First, from existing international law and the responsibilities of states
    • The Outer Space Treaty of 1967
    • I thought this created obligations regarding space
    • Space exploration was said to be for peaceful purposes
    • More than 100 countries participate
    • As state responsibility, it should be incorporated into domestic law and accountability should be demanded
    • States are held responsible for activities in space
    • Even for governmental entities
    • Non-governmental entities need authorization from the state
    • The jurisdiction model is unique
    • Each state is required to operate objects in a manner based on international law
      • For example, the same for the Internet
    • ITU
      • A legally binding initiative
      • Has the right to decide what telecommunications services to provide
      • There are also Radio Regulations
      • Also applicable to satellite services
      • Member states can suspend or restrict telecommunications
      • Satellite Internet access is included in this
    • Tampere Convention
      • Supports telecommunications during disasters
      • Adopted in 1998
  • Private Norm-Making
    • Safety in a peaceful manner
    • Technical standards
      • The IETF is also considering satellite communications
        • It is taking on the challenge
      • IRTF
        • GAIA
    • The ITU maintains its role of retaining legal binding force
      • Also develops responses and standards for disasters
      • Discussed as an international issue
  • Enforcement needs to be applied by states
    • The status of each country's efforts differs
    • Which companies it applies to
    • The same as telecommunications services
    • The same can be said of low Earth orbit satellites
    • When private companies enter into contracts, it differs by country
    • State responsibility
  • The Starlink case in Ukraine
    • What to do when a crisis occurs
  • It's not that there are no rules
    • On the contrary, there are many rules
    • The problem is how to implement them
    • Are there no court decisions or the like? Not yet
      • Some of this is technical
    • Engineers are the ones who can contribute
    • CCDCOE, COPUOS, etc.
    • Critical infrastructure is to be maintained even in space
    • There are rules regarding debris
    • There are also ITU recommendations
    • The UN also issues norms
  • There are also good examples
    • Also called space diplomacy
    • When providing satellite operations to individuals
    • UNGA Resolution 79/128
    • And the establishment of the right to connectivity
    • Due diligence is required
      • Who is involved
      • Regional or territorial application does not fit
      • By ensuring transparency, it is possible to understand who is making decisions
      • Accountability
      • It exists in the ITU as well

Impressions

Legal frameworks for new domains are also important.

It's a difficult area, but I hope they do their best.

Share this article